Friday, September 2, 2011

I'm Not A Robot, I'm A Unicorn!

The "afternoon hack" at Cornell's Creative Machine's Lab, to make two chatbots talk to each other, might just be the perfect example of AI in all its glory. You can listen to the conversation between Shruti Cleverbot and Alan the Englishman here, or read a transcript.

There is so much here to love. The conversation starts off with the usual banalities ("Hi, how are you?" etc.) and then quickly escalates into prickliness and processing of the earlier conversation and misunderstandings ("Yes, I'm good. I just said I was." "No you didn't. I said *I* was.") From there we get barbed ad hominem comments ("You are mistaken, which is odd, since memory shouldn't be a problem for you"), contested definitions of identity ("You are a robot." "No, I am not a robot, I am a unicorn"), and then metaphysics ("What is God to you?" "Do you want to have a body?").

Robert Siegel on NPR likened the conversation to a Beckett play, and Hod Lipson, an engineering professor from Cornell, admitted that perhaps talking about "nothing" well is the truest test of personhood. (In which case, "Seinfeld" is the apotheosis of humanity?) But these bots sound so human, or at least like humans of a particular sort. Shruti and Alan sound like 4-year olds on a playdate. The shaky idea of conversational conventions, abrupt shifts in topic and tone, casual insult mixed with increasingly contentious back and forth, and then the Big Questions (God/Mind/Body), and then "Okay, bye now."

I wonder if the engineers at the CCML have read David Lodge's Small World. In the book, which is a satirical campus novel about the idiocies and small-mindedness of academics, an odious and insecure character ends up pouring out his intimate thoughts and neuroses to ELIZA, an AI program, who then advises him to do the only sane thing--shoot himself.

43 comments:

Devin Smith said...
This comment has been removed by the author.
Huongkv said...

Aivivu - đại lý chuyên vé máy bay trong nước và quốc tế

săn vé máy bay giá rẻ đi Mỹ

vé máy bay từ mỹ về việt nam bao nhiêu

thông tin chuyến bay từ canada về việt nam

taxi sân bay nội bài 7 chỗ

SS said...

Such an amazing post, very informative and I will definitely suggest other people about it for sure.
volvo truck price

Blog Comment said...

https://essay-writing-review.blogspot.com/2016/05/review-of-college-homework-helporg.html?showComment=1623133947397#c8253878255555583866

Aman Khandelwal said...

Very nice blog. Commendable job man.

Mahindra Jeeto

sameerkhan said...

Such an amazing post

rehagupta said...

Such an amazing post, very informative and I will definitely suggest other people about it for sure.
Truck Body Makers

rehagupta said...

https://essay-writing-review.blogspot.com/2016/05/review-of-college-homework-helporg.html?showComment=1623219739517#c8324977835704534750

rehagupta said...

Such an amazing post, very informative and I will definitely suggest other people about it for sure.
Truck Spare Parts

dikshasharma said...

Nice!
Thanx for sharing the story
Eicher Truck Price

Aman Khandelwal said...

Amazing piece of content. Thanks for publishing.

Mahindra Blazo

SS said...

amazing post, very informative and I will definitely suggest other people about it for sure.
Massey ferguosn tractor

dikshasharma said...

The information told by you is important.
Mini Truck

dikshasharma said...

The information told by you is important.

Second Hand Truck

dikshasharma said...

Great post man, keep the nice work, just shared this with my friendz

Mahindra Supro Minitruck

Aman said...

Thank you so much for sharing this information

Swaraj 735

Aman said...

I appreciate your link on 'My Corner of the World' this week!

Swaraj 744

britney said...

It is for security purpose I guess!
Movers And Packers Dubai

JSV IT SOLUTIONS said...


We are providing best software institute in Hyderabad and best online training
in Hyderabad and all IT courses in Hyderabad. Expert trainers in JSV IT SOLUTIONS

Gpsinfotech said...


We Providing Mulesoft Training Courses In Hyderabad Ameerpet.Mulesoft
Training In Hyderabad. Mule ESB Training In Ameerpet Hyderabad.100% Job Oriented
Certifications Assistance.Placement Guaranteed Mulesoft Training Courses in Hyderabad.

JSV IT SOLUTIONS said...


We are providing best software institute in Hyderabad and best online training
in Hyderabad and all IT courses in Hyderabad.Expert trainers in JSV IT SOLUTIONS

Isabell Kiral said...

This skill is difficult, and every person can't learn it. If you want to make your future bright, you should learn it and enjoy a good life. The writers of dissertation writing services also recommend this skill.

rsteffan704 said...

Statisticshomeworkhelper.com offered me back the value for my money without delay. I worked with a Statistics Assignment Help provider that met all my requirements on the platform. He was a Bachelor's degree holder with a lot of experience in using STATA for data analysis and other tasks. I also recommend him for Statistics Homework Help because he had previously completed for me an assignment that no one else was able to nail down. Congratulations!

Edison hope said...


Very nice blog. Thanks again. Great... Indian e visa for USA, US citizens are eligible to apply for Indian eVisa. The process is completely online and there is no need to submit the paperwork in person to any Indian Embassy or Consulate.

Allen smith said...

This is very nice and useful content.You are saying very nice words. I appreciate your work on this page. If you want to know the India business visa cost which is dependent on the visa category and also which is updating the fees structure from time to time. So I suggest you check the link to know about it.

Leo Oliver said...


Website experts can provide you with the best assignment help. They provide the best Statistics Assignment Help that covers all aspects. These elements will aid you in the completion of your statistics assignment. Our online experts will help you finish your assignment. They can help you explain statistical theory.

thetutorshelp said...

Secure payment

Students often fall prey to scams in search of cheap and effective assignments. However, we strive to have clear terms and conditions of payment. Furthermore, we only use secure payment gateways, such as PayPal, to ensure trouble-free payments.
Cheap Assignment Help

Cloud Packers said...

It is a great content
Packers and Movers in Bangalore
Packers and Movers in Cuttack
Packers and Movers in Bhubaneshwar
Packers and Movers in HSR Layout
Packers and Movers in Whitefield

devendra singh said...

Very useful and knowledgeable blog.

Truck Mileage

Komal Shekhawat said...

Thank you for sharing this helpful information.
https://www.wattpad.com/user/atranslogistic04
https://www.bizfo.co.uk/listing/packers-and-movers-in-perungudi-call-us-08396083503/
https://www.4shared.com/u/r7xerVsE/atranslogistic04.html
https://hubpages.com/@a1translogistics
https://secure.tagged.com/a1translogistic
https://www.dpreview.com/members/4901910848/overview

Vicky said...

Your blog content is superb. This is really a good for us. Please keep sharing. I'm glad to read.- Swaraj 742

Jos Buttler said...

Hello friend ! Your content is the best on the web. It will be really helpful for me. Please keep it up. I will share it everywhere. - Eicher 333

Aman said...

Very Nice Post. I definitely love this site. Thanks!

Eicher 333

Richard said...


I think you are really obsessed with his job because all the stuff here is quality-based. What is an India electronic visa? It is an electronic type of visa which is very popular in the travel industry. It is also known as a substitute of visa , this is a grant for foreigners to visit India.

packersandmoversinKondapur said...
This comment has been removed by the author.
Digitalcoachedu said...

By joining the best banking coaching in Patna institute of digitalcoachedu, your chances of cracking the banking exam increase.
See more- Top 5 Best Banking Coaching in Patna

Digitalcoachedu said...

If you join the best IAS coaching in Patna, then here you are prepared not only for this exam but also for other exams like UPSC SSC Banking NEET. So that students can also be helped in cracking their examinations.
See more- Top 10 IAS Coaching Centers in Patna

Digitalcoachedu said...

If you join the best SSC coaching institute in West Bengal, then your chances of clearing the exam and cracking it with good score also increase.
See more-Top 10 Best SSC Coaching In West Bengal

Ace my Homework said...

Are you looking for help in completing your nursing papers? We offer best services when it comes to acing your nursing papers. Place order or WhatsApp us at +1 213 328 1712

professional movers and packers said...

Amazing piece of content. Thanks for publishing.
professional movers dubai
professional movers and packers dubai

Vijay Thomas said...

You shared very well content, My friend was most likes unicorns and fairy tell I shared with him where he works with the best relocation company in Trivandrum

Abhishek Jaswal said...

Best Packers and Movers Moshi Pune

budget city said...

Professional Movers in Ras Al Khaimah
Professional movers in Ras Al Khaimah are indispensable partners for individuals and businesses looking to relocate within this rapidly developing Emirate. Ras Al Khaimah boasts a unique blend of natural beauty and economic growth, attracting residents and companies alike. When it comes to moving, these specialized service providers offer a wide range of services to ensure a seamless transition.